Nonchalant Bon Vivant
Comments are encouraged; keep it civil, mind your manners; please read our before posting. Comments software by Hyvor; sign up to post with a user name, or post as a Guest anonymously.
Hitmaking Humbugs: Recording stars (1950-2000) who never made a Christmas record
Wednesday, December 16, 2020 10:16 AM
I collect Christmas records. I have in my collection, hundereds of discs, containing Christmas recordings by probably over a thousand artists. In my years of collecting, it struck me that, despite the ubiquity of pop star Christmas recordings, there were a few stars who never succumbed to the commercial pull to put out a holiday song. Below is my list of hitmakers who never released a Christmas/Holiday song.
Criteria for inclusion:
To make this list, an artist/band had to have had multiple Top 20 hits, singles or LP (US pop/C&W/R&B charts) between 1950-2000, and have never issued a Christmas/Holiday record (generic winter-themed songs that have become holiday standards, such as “Winter Wonderland” count). The Christmas recording could be released any year (hence, Dylan is not on this list). Limited edition/fan club releases OK (hence, the Beatles are not on the list). Additions/Corrections are most welcome in the comments section below.
The Humbug Hitmakers List:
Patsy Cline- Patsy did do a couple of duets of “Winter Wonderland” and “Let It Snow” for a TV show in 1959-60
Hank Williams- no, the depressing “First Fall of Snow” doesn’t count.
The Dave Clark Five
The Hollies- they did sing “Winter Wonderland” on the Ready Steady Go TV program in 1966
The Yardbirds- although original member Eric Clapton has released a Christmas LP
The GO-GO’s- although Belinda Carlisle did make a Christmas record
Sam & Dave
Crosby, Stills, Nash and Young- although Neil Young has guested on some Christmas recordings by friends.
Pink Floyd- they did do an original Christmas song as a one off for a BBC radio show.
Buddy Holly- had his career not been tragically cut short, I’m sure he would have recorded a Christmas song, probably an original composition.